A National Directory of Drug Treatment Centers and Alcohol Treatment Centers, Therapists and Specialists. A free, simple directory providing assistance and guidance for those seeking help regarding alcohol addiction, drug addiction, dependency and many other conditions that affect the mind, body and soul.
Call 888-647-0579 to speak with an alcohol or drug abuse counselor.

Who Answers?

The new smoking ban battleground: detox clinics

detox treatment clinics

Detox clinics can help you overcome your addiction to cigarettes.

Derek Laughlin, a 40-year-old former crack addict from Vancouver’s Downtown Eastside, found the cravings unbearable. Hours into treatment last year at a Surrey, B.C., short-term detox centre, on a staff-supervised walk around the block, he fell behind the group to search the pavement for discarded cigarette butts.

Overcoming his crack habit was tough, but simultaneously giving up smoking was too much, Mr. Laughlin says.

“It was brutal,” he says. “I’d be searching for cigarette butts wherever I could find them … and stressing out over when I was going to get another smoke.”

Canada has entered the next frontier for smoking bans: Many addiction facilities, forensic psychiatric hospitals for convicted criminals and federal prisons have recently banned smoking, sparking a heated debate among health practitioners about what is more important – weaning patients off cigarettes or helping them break free of hard drugs.

At detox centres, in particular, common wisdom has long held that it would be too difficult for patients addicted to drugs or alcohol to stop smoking while they are fighting a dependency on harder drugs that pose a more immediate threat to their health.

But while experiences like those of Mr. Laughlin are common, studies now point to the long-term benefits of prohibiting smoking at detox clinics.

Louise Walker, a researcher with the Toronto-based Centre for Addiction and Mental Health, said a deeper understanding of addiction triggers and the dangers of tobacco has changed the consensus on the best ways to treat users.

Most of the recent research has shown patients who receive nicotine patches or inhalers during addiction treatment have a better chance of beating their heroin and crack addictions, she says.

“It’s like restaurants and malls were years ago,” she says. “It’s just taking some time to become normal.”

At Larson House, a short-term detox centre in Saskatoon’s Pleasant Hill neighbourhood, patients stay for an average of one week.

Last year, health officials banned patients from smoking once they check in. Treatment for nicotine addiction was made available to all clients.

Michelle Robson, program manager for mental health and addiction services for the Saskatoon Health Region, says only a few clients opposed the policy change.

“We should be remiss as health care providers for not addressing that smoking is the leading cause of preventable death,” Ms. Robson says. “I question utilizing unhealthy behaviours to help people quit. I don’t know the difference between that and offering somebody alcohol.”

But some front-line workers are not convinced. Lynne Sabo, director of the Regina Detox Centre, a non-profit facility that has not banned smoking, said since other detox centres in Saskatchewan banned smoking she has had dozens of people travel to her clinic to receive treatment so they can get help while continuing to smoke.

She says prohibiting smoking is a restrictive measure that can cause patients to leave facilities before receiving proper treatment, and can deter some addicts from checking in.

Ms. Sabo worries the smoking bans are predominantly in place to serve non-smoking employees, but are indiscriminately ensnaring addicts.

The Regina Detox Centre, like many in Canada, has a small gazebo where smokers can light up. As an arms-length facility, it has not been caught in the province’s non-smoking policy.

“People aren’t coming to detox to quit smoking,” Ms. Sabo says.

“From my experience, smoking actually helps people with other withdrawals they’re going through. Patients aren’t checking in to a smoking detox. That’s not our job”

In Vancouver, some detox facilities ban smoking while others take a harm-reduction approach, even giving free cigarettes away.

In 2005, most detox centres in British Columbia came under a ban that prohibited smoking in all provincial health facilities.

The move was especially problematic for youth detox centres. Once overflowing with patients, their occupancy dropped off. Most reacted quickly, building on-site gazebos or ignoring the ban.

Cannon Singh, executive director of Vancouver’s Downtown Eastside Youth Activities Society, which runs a short-term detox centre for youth, scoffs at the restrictions.

Last year, the province cut the organization’s funding for providing free cigarettes to youth, but the detox centre has continued to hand them out.

Once an addict himself, Mr. Singh says smoking bans are another hurdle to getting youth to walk through the doors.

What’s more, Mr. Singh says, most smokers will go back to lighting up once they check out to cope with continuing drug withdrawal symptoms.

Mr. Laughlin, for instance, immediately took up smoking again when he left the detox centre, but he says he hasn’t used drugs since.

Mr. Singh says the bans prove to be a significant hurdle for recovering addicts, who as a group tend to be committed and heavy smokers. Recent studies have estimated that more than 90 per cent of addicts smoke, compared with less than 20 per cent of the general population.

“It’s a huge barrier,” Mr. Singh says. “The question you have to ask is whether you want someone smoking cigarettes or battling a heroin addiction.”

To ban or not to ban

Recent studies shed light on the smoking ban dilemma facing Canadian detox clinics. Some studies found that there are short- and long-term benefits when addicts are forced to give up smoking while recovering. But others questioned prohibiting smoking given the more pressing problem of detoxifying from hard drugs. Here’s a sample of recent research on the subject:

STUDY TITLE “Don’t you think we’re giving up enough already?”

LEAD RESEARCHER Robert Hill, psychology professor, University of Utah

JOURNAL Substance Use, August 2007

CONCLUSIONS The study interviewed 38 patients and 39 staff from detox facilities in the United States about their attitudes toward implementing smoking bans. The staff recognized the health benefits of a no-smoking policy, but said they thought a smoking ban would increase the likelihood of addicts leaving early. Most patients said they wanted to quit smoking, but were more concerned about breaking free of hard drugs first.

STUDY TITLE “Barriers and solutions to addressing tobacco dependence in addiction treatment programs”

LEAD RESEARCHER Douglas Ziedonis, psychiatry professor, University of Massachusetts

JOURNAL Alcohol Research & Health, Summer 2006

CONCLUSIONS The study compared patients who quit smoking, with the aid of nicotine patches or inhalers, to those who continued to smoke during detox treatment. Those who quit smoking responded to the detox from hard drugs at a faster rate. The benefits of banning smoking also included less haggling about smoke breaks, less coercion of smokers by staff and an increased likelihood patients would complete treatment.

STUDY TITLE “Changes in cigarette smoking among alcohol and drug misusers during inpatient detoxification”

LEAD RESEARCHER Jennifer Harris, researcher, U.K. National Addiction Centre

JOURNAL Addiction Biology, June 2006

CONCLUSIONS The study examined 135 patients at an alcohol and drug detox clinic in the United States. Almost all of the patients smoked regularly before entering the clinic, consuming an average of 27 cigarettes a day. A week after the patients left the smoke-free detox, the number of cigarettes smoked decreased by more than 10 cigarettes a day among heavy smokers but increased by more than 8 cigarettes a day among light smokers.
________
source: The Globe and Mail, http://www.theglobeandmail.com

More Treatment & Detox Articles

Adults no help to teenage drinkers

What would you do? A 16-year-old comes up to you and asks for a little help. He and his friends are bored and just want to have a little fun that night. He asks you to buy booze. Got a problem with that? The Pittsfield Prevention Partnership says you should, but not everyone does. And….

Continue reading

The AbuseCheck Hair Alcohol Test

From a Small Sample of Hair, This Test Can Distinguish Non-Drinkers from Moderate and Abusive Drinkers Alcoholism poses serious health issues with major socio-economic consequences to society. Four major areas of concern are public transportation, child custody rights, measuring underage drinking, and tools for monitoring rehabilitation. The Omnibus Transportation Employee Testing Act of 1991 requires….

Continue reading

Governments’ Drug-Abuse Costs Hit $468 Billion, Study Says

Government spending related to smoking and the abuse of alcohol and illegal drugs reached $468 billion in 2005, accounting for more than one-tenth of combined federal, state and local expenditures for all purposes, according to a new study. Most abuse-related spending went toward direct health care costs for lung disease, cirrhosis and overdoses, for example,….

Continue reading

SOS offers addiction recovery without religion

For atheists who are addicted to alcohol or drugs, recovery programs that urge reliance on a “higher power” can be problematic. What is this higher power? Despite protestations to the contrary, the term is obviously meant as a synonym for God. Substituting “nature,” “or “science” or some such thing doesn’t quite cut it. There is….

Continue reading

Aversion Therapy for Alcohol Addiction Treatment

Aversion therapy is a type of therapy that teaches an alcoholic to associate some type of negative outcome with getting drunk. Aversion therapy is a way of conditioning the recovering alcoholic to not like alcohol because of the negative effects that alcohol has on them thus breaking the cycle of addiction. Aversion therapy can be….

Continue reading

Calls to the general helpline will be answered by a paid advertiser. By calling the helpline you agree to our terms of use.

I NEED TO TALK TO SOMEONE NOWI NEED TO TALK TO SOMEONE NOW 888-647-0579Response time about 1 min | Response rate 100%
Who Answers?