A National Directory of Drug Treatment Centers and Alcohol Treatment Centers, Therapists and Specialists. A free, simple directory providing assistance and guidance for those seeking help regarding alcohol addiction, drug addiction, dependency and many other conditions that affect the mind, body and soul.
Call 800-580-9104 to speak with an alcohol or drug abuse counselor.

Addiction Advances Haven’t Made AA Obsolete

Although they approach the challenge of addiction differently from scientists, 12-step programs still have a therapeutic role in helping human beings.

Alcoholics Anonymous may have pioneered the concept of alcoholism as a disease, but will scientific research that proves the point eventually make AA obsolete?

Studies that reveal brain and genetic links to addiction seem to suggest that future cures may come in pill boxes or, even better, in vials of vaccine that prevent it to begin with. Surely, that could impact 12-step programs that have been the prototype of recovery regimes for three quarters of a century.

It’s an intriguing issue invited by imaging studies that have identified differences in addicts’ brains, including a 2007 British report headed by Cambridge nueroscientist Jeff Dalley that showed rats with reduced dopamine receptors are more likely to become compulsive users of cocaine. Dopamine is a neurotransmitter associated with emotion and motivation. If the same deficiency identified in rats is found in humans, scientists say, some of us are born with a predisposition to addiction.

Alcoholics Anonymous Group

Alcoholics Anonymous is still running strong.

Two million alcoholics in 180 countries around the world are members of AA, according to its Web site. There are countless others who attend meetings of Narcotics Anonymous and Cocaine Anonymous, and other progeny of AA. So, what’s the implication of this research on these vast networks of fellowship recovery programs?

Not as much as you’d think.

“We’ve had a great deal of emphasis on the neuroscience of addiction. Some people mistakenly think that would mean there’s no role for social support in recovery,” said Wilson Compton, senior scientist at the National Institute on Drug Abuse, a department of the National Institutes of Health.

While current and future medications may improve treatment of addiction by blocking intoxication, easing withdrawal symptoms and inhibiting cravings, they’ll supplement 12-step programs rather than replace them.

“We don’t have the kind of medications that turn on or turn off a disease like alcoholism or drug addiction,” Compton said. “And I don’t think we will in the foreseeable future have such a medication.”

Medication can help people make the changes necessary to manage their addiction, and for many of those people, “recovery support services are absolutely essential,” Compton said.

When AA was founded in 1935, it embraced the theory proposed two centuries earlier by Dr. Benjamin Rush: that alcoholism was a biological malady beyond the control of the addict. Dr. Elvin Jellinek confirmed the theory in a landmark 1960 book, Disease Concept of Alcoholism. The concept was subsequently endorsed by major medical associations and eventually became conventional wisdom — though it’s not without its fierce critics.

But AA’s disease model was as much ideology as biology, meant as counterpoint to the popular belief that alcoholism was a moral lapse or a failure of will. The sophisticated studies of today are attempting to identify the actual mechanism of the disease, which reinforces the original AA model but also raises hopes for a “cure” through medical intervention — false hopes, it appears, at this point.

Mark Willenbring, director of treatment and recovery research at the National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism, said the brain studies need to be “taken with a grain of salt.”

“Most of what you hear are extrapolations from studies on rodents. Rodents are not humans. And there are no rodent alcoholics. In the wild, you don’t see rodents being drunk or snorting cocaine.”

Not to mention that the research, as presented in the mainstream media — consider the portrayal of a synapse that many of us have seen — “grossly oversimplifies the brain,” Willenbring said, leading to false assumptions about the role of genetics and brain structure in the treatment of addiction.

“There are more neuronal connections in the brain than there are stars in the universe.

“The most important functions of the brain can’t be directly perceived because they’re a result of the interaction of multiple, probably hundreds of different places in the brain all at once. Our ability to model these things is extremely primitive,” Willenbring said.

Nor are there one or two abnormal genes that “cause” addiction that could simply be fixed.

“People tend to think there’s a gene or a couple of genes and if you have those, it’s determinative. It’s not determinative,” Willenbring said.

“The genetics are very complex involving hundreds of genes, each contributing a tiny bit to the overall variability in expression.”

Willenbring emphasizes that the environment plays a crucial role in determining whether genes will be expressed at all. And life experience also impacts the brain itself, he said, changing brain structure and function in ways that impact behavior, which helps explain why interventions such as AA can be effective even without other treatment.

“We learn in various ways and one of them is by seeing somebody else do something. There’s a specific neurological system called mirror neurons involved in this kind of learning. So AA newcomers get to see what sober people are like,” he said.

AA also “provides a social context of support and understanding, and an alternative social group distinct from the drinking group. … There’s lots and lots of folk wisdom, collective wisdom about how to successfully stop and stay stopped.”

And the experience of attending regular meetings changes addicts’ brains, Willenbring said.

“If people change their behavior and outlook and attitudes, then of course it’s reflected in changes in the brain,” he said.

Alcoholics Anonymous would not comment for this article, adhering to its policy of anonymity and avoidance of all public discourse. AA takes no positions on any controversy and, in fact, has no executive or figurehead to speak for the organization at all.

“We’re just amateurs here,” a staff spokesperson said when asked for comment.

AA need not defend its role in recovery anyway. Clearly, there’s no belief that such 12-step fellowship programs will ever become obsolete.

“When I treat patients with alcohol dependence, I routinely recommend medications, and I also recommend AA,” Willenbring said.

“There’s no incompatibility at all.”

source: Miller-McCune Online Magazine

More Treatment & Detox Articles

Adventure helps boy beat alcohol problem

15-year-old who woke each morning wanting a drink has sobered up after therapy involving mountain biking and abseiling. The boy who spent eight months on a Christchurch City Mission adventure therapy course agreed to speak to The Press after an Otago University study into the care of young people with alcohol and drug problems. The….

Continue reading

Is Executive Drug Treatment Right for Me?

Substance abuse is a serious problem that affects thousands of people both rich and poor. Suffering from drug addiction does not have to be the end of your career and you don’t have to feel like there is no hope for you if you are a business professional who is addicted to drugs. Executive drug….

Continue reading

The New Direction

Giving the Alcoholic Person a Successful Start on the Twelve-Step Road of Recovery Since 1977 The New Direction Alcohol Rehabilitation in New York The New Direction was founded in 1977 by Matt and Margaret Batson under the premise that people who make a commitment to A.A. tend to stay sober. Since the doors of the….

Continue reading

The Painful Truth about Heroin Detox

Heroin Detox Program

Thousands of heroin uses claim that they don’t get treatment for their addiction simply because they are too afraid of having to go through withdrawal during detox. In fact, many would rather use heroin and remain addicted to this deadly drug than actually deal with the pain and discomforts that come during withdrawal. The truth….

Continue reading

Warning signs of eating disorder

Eating disorder is largely related to the psychological disturbances that occur in a person. There are two main categories of eating disorder namely, anorexia nervosa and bulimia nervosa. The people with anorexia nervosa are very much concerned about their looks and carry a fear of weight gain thus avoiding intake of food. On the contrary,….

Continue reading